migrationagent.org

Global

UK Earned Settlement: Care Workers Offered a Five-Year Path, but Family and Benefit Cases Remain Unclear

Shabana Mahmood’s earned settlement policy offers eligible care workers a five-year path, but questions remain over British-citizen partners, benefit claims and the 10-year route.

Published 8 Nov 2026 · Checked on 2026-11-08

What changed on 2 November 2026

On 2 November 2026, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood made an oral statement to Parliament on the government’s “earned settlement” policy. The Home Office said the right to live in the UK permanently will no longer be granted almost automatically after five years and will instead be earned. The published model set a three-year route for the highest earners, a five-year route for people earning more than £50,271 and some public service workers such as doctors, nurses and teachers, a 10-year default for others, and at least 20 years for people who breached immigration rules. Anyone seeking settlement will first need to meet four non-negotiable conditions. The supplied extract does not list those four conditions, so the announcement does not answer every eligibility question on its own.

Which parts are policy, and which are operative rules?

The 2 November material is an oral statement and a Home Office news release, not a commencement order or amended Rules text in the supplied pack. The statement says settlement rules are determined when a settlement decision is made, not when someone arrives. The news release says settlement rules will otherwise continue to apply at the point of application, as they always have. No parliamentary timetable or commencement date for the Immigration Rules changes appears in the supplied statements.

That leaves a gap between the announcement and an operative rule that an applicant can rely on.

Why reactions split

The Guardian reported on 7 November 2026 that some relatives of British citizens felt left behind, while the announcement brought relief to many care workers. Under pressure from Labour MPs and unions, the Home Secretary offered qualifying care workers a five-year settlement route. Rasika Samarasinghe, who arrived from Sri Lanka in October 2022 and earns just over £25,000 caring for elderly people, was planning a double celebration after the Home Office reversed its refusal to let his wife and three children remain as his dependants. Samarasinghe said, “I feel free now”. Aneisha Williams said, “We were never told this would happen, and never would have taken the help if we did, even though my past situation was very grim”. Williams also called the policy racist and said it made her feel further hopeless. Dr Dora-Olivia Vicol, chief executive of the Work Rights Centre, called the response, apart from the care-worker concessions, “bitterly disappointing” and said it was “deeply unfair” that some workers who came expecting a five-year route would now wait 10 years. The Home Office estimates about 500,000 people will have to wait longer than five years, which officials say will save billions from the welfare bill.

Care workers: five-year path, £25,000 threshold and dependants

Under the revised plans, care workers who entered the route before May 2025 and earn at least £25,000 a year can qualify after five years, rather than the 15 years originally proposed. The transitional arrangement applies only to people who joined before the government published its Immigration White Paper in May 2025. The Home Office says care workers who earned £25,000 a year in the social care sector, which was the condition of their visa, can settle on the existing five-year path. Care workers who do not qualify, around a quarter of the total, will be offered a new five-year visa and can apply for settlement only after completing it. The occupation codes in the Skilled Worker guidance are 6135 for care workers and home carers and 6136 for senior care workers, with 6145 and 6146 for certificates of sponsorship assigned before 4 April 2024. In England, applicants sponsored for 6135 or 6136 must work for an employer registered with the Care Quality Commission, and the sponsor must be carrying out CQC-regulated activities and not be dormant. Care workers or senior care workers sponsored before 11 March 2024 do not need a CQC-registered sponsor if they extend with the same sponsor, provided their original application date was before 11 March 2024. Dependant partners and children can apply on the Skilled Worker route, but there are exceptions for dependants of care workers, senior care workers and medium-skilled roles. New restrictions applied from 11 March 2024 to care worker and senior care worker applicants applying for or with dependants. Similar restrictions applied from 22 July 2025 to medium-skilled roles below RQF 6 on the Immigration Salary List or the Temporary Shortage List. The Guardian reported that care workers have been barred from bringing family since March 2024 and that overseas recruitment was banned from July 2025.

The care-worker concession is narrower than a general five-year route for everyone in social care.

British-citizen partners and former partners

The Home Secretary said family members of British citizens will retain existing settlement pathways. The same report says how that protection applies to people whose marriages have broken down, or who claimed benefits, remains unclear. Home Office caseworker guidance covers settlement on the five-year family route, the 10-year family route under Appendix Settlement Family Life, and bereaved partners. That guidance tells caseworkers how to consider settlement applications by people on the family life, private life and bereaved partner routes. Where a marriage or civil partnership has not been legally dissolved, the family life guidance says an applicant may still qualify under Appendix FM as an unmarried partner if they meet the criteria and provide evidence that the new relationship is genuine and subsisting and the previous relationship has broken down permanently. Appendix FM provides two routes to settlement on the basis of family life as a partner or parent: a five-year route and a 10-year route. Aneisha Williams, a supermarket worker from London, married a British man in Jamaica and joined him in the UK in 2016. During the Covid crisis her marriage broke down, leaving her homeless while she was on a family life visa. Her no-recourse-to-public-funds restriction was lifted in a hardship case, and she claimed housing benefit. She was months from qualifying for indefinite leave to remain after 10 years, but under the plans the benefit claim could delay settlement for years.

The policy sentence about “existing settlement pathways” does not resolve the broken-marriage or benefit-claim scenarios in the supplied material.

Does a past hardship benefit claim count against the five-year test?

The plan requires applicants to have spent five continuous years without relying on benefits. Last year, Mahmood proposed adding up to 10 years to the settlement qualifying period for benefit claimants. A person with no recourse to public funds cannot claim public funds unless an exception applies. Claiming a benefit that is a public fund when no exception applies can put a person in breach of immigration conditions and lead to leave being cancelled or curtailed, or a future leave application being refused. Some people with limited leave can apply to the Home Office to have the NRPF condition lifted if they are destitute or at imminent risk of destitution. Williams obtained that change of conditions in hardship and claimed housing benefit. The supplied material does not say whether those benefit years will be disregarded or counted against the five continuous years without benefits. The policy statement refers to four non-negotiable conditions but does not set them out in the supplied extract.

The 10-year route, transitional protection and pending applications

The government plans to end the 10-year long-residence route. Ashley, a civil servant from Sheffield, arrived from the US in 2017 and moved from student and graduate visas to a spouse visa after marrying a British man in 2025. She expected to qualify in 2027 under the 10-year route. With transitional arrangements unclear, she fears waiting until 2030, by which time she estimates she will have spent £25,000 on visa and healthcare charges. The statement says settlement rules are determined when a settlement decision is made, not at the point when someone arrives. The news release says settlement rules will otherwise continue to apply at the point of application. The supplied material does not set out transitional protection for people already on the 10-year route or say what happens to an ILR application already submitted.

Anyone already on the route therefore faces two separate questions: whether a protection applies, and which version of the Rules governs a decision.

Fees, timing and what the pack does not cover

The supplied material does not include current Home Office application fees or Immigration Health Surcharge rates. It reports Ashley’s estimate that a wait to 2030 could mean £25,000 in visa and healthcare charges, which is her estimate rather than a published fee schedule. No commencement date or parliamentary timetable for the earned settlement Rules appears in the 2 November statements. The Home Office estimate that about 500,000 people will wait longer than five years, saving billions from the welfare bill, is the only system-level timing impact in the pack. The pack does not include the legal-adviser register or a document checklist for evidencing residence, salary or periods without benefits.

Questions applicants are asking

Does the five-year care-worker route already apply?

The care-worker concession was announced as part of the earned settlement policy on 2 November 2026. The supplied statements give no commencement date for the Immigration Rules change. The announced criteria are entry before May 2025, at least £25,000 a year and work in the social care sector that was the condition of the visa. People who do not qualify may be offered a new five-year visa before settlement.

Do British-citizen partners keep their existing settlement route after divorce?

The Home Secretary said family members of British citizens will retain existing settlement pathways. The report says it is unclear how that applies to broken-down marriages. Caseworker guidance covers five-year and 10-year family routes and bereaved partners. It also addresses unmarried-partner cases where a previous marriage has not been legally dissolved and the previous relationship has broken down permanently. The pack does not state that the new protection overrides those case-specific rules.

Will housing benefit received under an NRPF hardship grant block settlement?

The plan requires five continuous years without relying on benefits. The pack does not say whether lawful housing benefit received after an NRPF condition was lifted will count against that test. It does say claiming public funds without an exception can breach immigration conditions and affect leave. It also says the policy’s application to benefit claimants remains unclear.

What happens to people already on the 10-year route?

The government plans to end the 10-year long-residence route. The pack does not set out transitional protection or what happens to pending ILR applications. It does say settlement rules are determined when a decision is made, not when someone arrived. It also says rules apply at the point of application.

What fees will applicants pay while waiting?

The pack does not include current Home Office fees or Immigration Health Surcharge rates. It reports one applicant’s estimate of £25,000 in visa and healthcare charges if she waits until 2030. That figure is an individual estimate, not an official fee table.

Source note

Sources used: Home Office, “Earned settlement” oral statement, 2 November 2026; Home Office, “Home Secretary unveils new rules for migrants settling in the UK”, 2 November 2026; The Guardian, report published 7 November 2026; Home Office, “Skilled Worker caseworker guidance”, 4 January 2023; Home Office, “Settlement: family life, private life and bereaved partners”, published for Home Office staff 17 August 2026; Home Office, “Family life (as a partner or parent) and exceptional circumstances”, 30 December 2025; NRPF Network, “Who has no recourse to public funds (NRPF)”, undated.

Sources

Checked on 2026-11-08. Immigration rules change without notice — check the linked source before you rely on a figure.

Stuck on a case?

Ask about your case

Tell us what you are applying for and where you are stuck. You will get a plain answer about what the application has to prove — not a sales pitch.

Ask MigrationAgent.org

General information, not immigration advice for your case.

Contact

Ask about your case

Tell us what you are applying for and where you are stuck. You will get a plain answer about what the application has to prove — not a sales pitch.

Include: the destination, the visa or route you are on, your current status, and any deadline or refusal you are working against. That is enough to give you a straight answer about what the application has to prove.

General information, not immigration advice for your case.

Ask MigrationAgent.org